Exxon/Climate Change - Climate Shareholder Vote to Proceed After Exxon Fails to Kill it at SEC
Jo-Carolyn Goode | 3/21/2016, 3:34 p.m.
In Midst of Exxon Climate Controversy and Post-Paris Momentum, Shareholders Can Urge Oil Giants to Return More Capital to Investors, Favoring Value as High Cost High Carbon Growth Assets Likely to Go Untapped.
BOSTON///March 21, 2016///As Exxon and Chevron face increasingly serious climate change headwinds, the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has cleared the way for shareholders to weigh in on the strategic direction of the beleaguered oil giants. Climate-related resolutions filed by investment managers Arjuna Capital and Baldwin Brothers Inc., have survived challenges mounted by both companies at the SEC.
This is the first year a shareholder proposal asking ExxonMobil to prioritize returning more capital to shareholders in light of increasingly risky investments in potentially stranded carbon assets will be put to the ballot. Exxon was able last year to dodge the proxy measure at the SEC arguing their dividend had been increasing, despite a precipitous decline in total capital distributions and lack of a serious climate strategy. But the SEC ruled in favor of the proponents, given three years of consecutive drops in Exxon capital distributions and an unwillingness to address the risk of unburnable carbon at the companies.
This is the second year the ballot measure will be put to a vote at Chevron Corp.
The shareholder proposals call on Exxon and Chevron to protect investor value by committing to increasing the total amount authorized for capital distributions (summing dividends and share buybacks) to shareholders as a prudent use of investor capital in light of the climate change related risks of stranded carbon assets.
A link to the ExxonMobil proposal is available online at: http://arjuna-capital.com/sites/default/files/XOM%20Capital%20Distribution%20Proposal%202016.pdf. The SEC Exxon decision is available online at: https://www.sec.gov/divisions/corpfin/cf-noaction/14a-8/2016/ericmccallum031416-14a8.pdf. The Chevron decision is available at: http://www.arjuna-capital.com/sites/default/files/SEC%20Decision_CVX_inchessessums031116-14a8.pdf.
Natasha Lamb, director of research & shareholder engagement at Arjuna Capital, a division of Baldwin Brothers said: Exxon and Chevron have been outright recalcitrant on climate, denying it will have any meaningful impact on their business. The oil majors are in the business of selling carbon, so how can they possibly be insulated from carbon asset risk? The SEC has done its job, upholding investors right to weigh in on an issue so critical to Big Oils future, yet so blatantly absent from Exxon and Chevrons agenda.
In 2014, ExxonMobil wrote a report in response to Arjuna Capital/Baldwin Brothers and As You Sow on the potential for unburnable stranded carbon assets, following a landmark negotiation with the shareholders. ExxonMobil has maintained that none of its carbon assets will be stranded, based on their internal projections of unabated global energy demand and a belief that global governments will not take meaningful action to curb global warming.
Exxon and Chevron are pushing up against a shifting tide, said Lamb. Denial is no longer a credible business plan. Smart fossil fuel companies focus on value over growth this century. Growth for growths sake is a fools errand when society cant burn all the carbon we already have. If they continue down that path, they will end up like the coal companies.
HSBC has warned the equity value of oil producers could drop 40 to 60 percent under a low carbon scenario. And Citigroup notes 40 percent of current oil investments are stranded at prices below 75 dollars per barrel.
For more information, visit http://corporate.exxonmobil.com/