Outrage in India as teacher tells students to slap classmate who is Muslim

CNN/Stylemagazine.com Newswire | 8/28/2023, 12:52 p.m.
Police in India are investigating a teacher after a video of her encouraging students to slap their 7-year-old classmate, who …

Originally Published: 28 AUG 23 04:53 ET

Updated: 28 AUG 23 11:44 ET

By Rhea Mogul, Manveena Suri and Irene Nasser, CNN

New Delhi (CNN) — Police in India are investigating a teacher after a video of her encouraging students to slap their 7-year-old classmate, who is Muslim, sparked widespread outrage in the country.

CNN Video

Viral video of a teacher asking students to slap a fellow classmate sparks outrage

A school in India has been ordered by district officials to shut down after a video emerged showing a teacher asking students to slap a fellow classmate who is Muslim, according to CNN affiliate CNN News18. CNN's Vedika Sud has more. Source: CNN

The video of the incident, which took place in the Muzaffarnagar district in northern Uttar Pradesh state, shows the boy fearfully standing in front of his classmates as the teacher calls on students to hit him.

The boy cries as his classmates take turns to slap him, while the teacher is heard telling the students to do it “properly.” A man can be heard laughing as the boy wails while the slapping continues.

Muzaffarnagar’s superintendent of police, Satyanarayan Prajapat, on Friday said the teacher told students to hit the boy “for not remembering his times tables.”

The teacher also referenced the boy’s religion, according to Prajapat.

“The female teacher declared: ‘When the mothers of Mohammedan (one who follows Islam) students don’t pay attention to their children’s studies, their performance is ruined,” he said.

Police in the district have registered a case against the teacher and an investigation is underway. The teacher has not been formally charged. District officials have also ordered the school to shut, according to CNN affiliate CNN News-18.

CNN has reached out to Uttar Pradesh police officials for more details.

The boy’s father told CNN that his son felt “restless and scared” after the incident on Thursday. He said that, while the boy is doing much better now, he “was unable to sleep earlier and was left in shock” afterward.

He told CNN that his son has since been admitted to another school and attended his first day on Monday, after Neha Public School – where the incident took place – was ordered to shut down.

The incident has caused widespread anger and upset in India, the world’s largest democracy of 1.4 billion, where the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party’s (BJP) Hindu nationalist policies have deepened the country’s communal tensions and created what rights groups and government critics say is an atmosphere of fear and alienation among minority groups.

Prominent opposition politician Rahul Gandhi accused the teacher of “sowing the poison of discrimination in the minds of innocent children.” Writing on Twitter, now known as X, he said: “Turning a holy place like school into a market place of hatred – there is nothing worse than this that a teacher can do for the country.”

Gandhi also blamed the BJP for stoking religious intolerance.

“This is the same kerosene spread by the BJP which has set every corner of India on fire,” Gandhi wrote. “Children are the future of India - do not hate them, we all have to teach love together.”

While the BJP has not responded to Gandhi’s comments, it has long maintained it does not discriminate against minorities and “treats all its citizens with equality.” During a trip to the United States in June, Prime Minister Narendra Modi told reporters there was “absolutely no space” for discrimination in India.

Indian law does not have a statutory definition of corporal punishment targeting children, however physical punishment and mental harassment are prohibited under the country’s Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Act.

According to CNN News-18, the teacher claimed the 7-year-old’s father had asked her to punish the child, adding that she was unable to do so because she is disabled and had therefore told the other students to discipline him.

“His father brought the child in and said to straighten him out. Now because I can’t get up, I thought I’d get one or two children to hit him,” she said.

The incident comes at a time of heightened communal tensions in the country as the BJP’s popular but divisive policies gain momentum in India.

A study by economist Deepankar Basu noted a 786% increase in hate crimes against all minorities between 2014 and 2018, following the BJP’s election victory.

Uttar Pradesh, where the incident took place, is India’s largest state of about 200 million. It boasts a religiously diverse population, where about 20% of its residents are Muslim.

However, it remains among one of the most polarized of states in India.

Its chief minister, the Hindu-monk-turned BJP politician Yogi Adityanath, has been criticized for his anti-Muslim rhetoric and Hindu-first policies, and the state has passed legislation critics say is rooted in “Hindutva” – the ideological bedrock of Hindu nationalism.